I have had bats in my barn for years, see them in the morning when out with the dogs. A couple of questions. I am in W Mass area. I built a 3 chamber house (BCI plans) stained black, facing WSW. Located within 6 ft of the old window in the barn that the bats use. No residents in 2 yrs. I had the back half of my barn recovered due to water problems. The contractor used plywood sheeting over the existing batten boards. I don't know as if this removed roosting spaces.
I have another 3 chamber that I did not stain yet. I was thinking brown or slate grey and moving from WSW to SSE exposure.
The other day I noticed about 20 or so bats going into my neighbors house right at the metal ridge cap. They have a slate roof. Did I move the bats, or they were always at the neighbors also? I am trying to encourage roosting in my area for insect control and helping bat population recover.
Thanks for any and all replies-
Herb

Since you have had no luck yet and seem to want to try something different. I suggest moving the existing dark house to the SSE location (or even face it due east if possible) and putting the new lighter colored house near where the old one was. Perhaps Terry or Frank can refine this further.